18 April 2024 last updated at 15:13 GMT
LKM Press Release
Appeal against ED order on IPL SA 2009

Against the order dated 31st May,18 passed by the Special Director of Enforcement Directorate (ED) Mumbai, Lalit Kumar Modi, former IPL Commissioner has preferred an appeal before the Appellate Tribunal at New Delhi. Under the said order a penalty of Rs. 10,65,00000.00 has been levied on him.


The appeal is based against the erroneous findings of the adjudicating authority whereby he held Lalit Modi was responsible for shifting of 2ndSeason (2009) of IPL to South Africa and transfer of BBCI funds to Cricket South Africa (CSA) and other financial transactions connected with it without seeking  RBI permission. Along with BCCI others like N. Srinivasan, M.P.Pandov, then Secretary and Treasurer of BCCI and A.K. Nazir Khan, then Manager of the State Bank of Travancore have been held guilty and have been levied penalties.


Firstly, the adjudicating authority has erred by holding the transfer of funds from BBCI to CSA as capital account payment whereas; it was current account payment for which no RBI permission was required. This is the position taken by State of India, SBI ( as now the State Bank of Travancore stands merged into SBI)


Moreover, as the Board of Control for Cricket in India is a society registered under the provisions of Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act and Rules 1975. The office bearers of BCCI are: President; Secretary; Joint Secretary and treasurer who are responsible for the conduct of affairs of BCCI; this is a fact which has been noticed in the ED complaint dated 16/11/2011 itself and impugned order as well.


The affairs of BCCI are conducted by the general body, the Working Committee of BCCI, and office bearers of BCCI. BCCI has various subcommittees as well like: Legal Committee; Marketing Committee; Finance Committee; etc. Such committees assist and aid in the smooth functioning of the BCCI. However such committees/subcommittees do not have a separate legal identity and chairpersons of such committees are neither office bearers of BCCI nor are they responsible for conduct of affairs of BCCI.


That, in the General Body Meeting of BCCI dated 28/09/2007 it was decided that Mr N Srinivasan who was then the Honorary Secretary of BCCI would open and operate a new bank account in the name of BCCI – IPL. Thus all financial transactions and financial decisions relating to BCCI – IPL were responsibilities of Mr N Srinivasan. However, as it appears no such separate new bank account was opened by Mr N Srinivasan. In fact, all remittances/transactions which are subject matter of the impugned order have been made from the account of the BCCI itself where Lalit Modi had no control over the day to day affairs or any financial power.


In the working committee meeting dated 22/03/2009 it was decided that IPL tournament for the IPL Season – 2 should be shifted out of the country either to England or South Africa. This decision as to finally deciding the venue was left to Mr Shashank Manohar who was then the president of BCCI.


It was also decided that BCCI would open a bank account after obtaining clearance from RBI and the said account will be operated by the honorary treasurer Mr M.P Pandove.


With regard to the opening of the bank account after obtaining clearance from RBI, an appropriate resolution was to be framed by the then honorary secretary of BCCIi.e Mr N.Srinivasan.


That it is noteworthy that during the entire investigation this aspect has not been investigated, whether honorary secretary Mr N Srinivasan had framed a resolution in terms of the decision taken in the working committee meeting dated 22/03/2009?  And, if no such resolution was drafted by him what was the reason for not drafting such resolution in terms of the decision already taken by the working committee.


Other grounds for filing the appeal are that entire adjudication proceedings have been held in violation of principles of natural justice, this violation of principles of natural justice had many facets like refusal to provide a copy of reply filed by the Main noticee (BCCI).


Refusal to provide a copy of the reply filed by Authorised Dealer and other noticees; refusal to even grant inspection of the file before final arguments.

Separate holding of the proceedings with respect to each of the noticees and the joint holding proceedings was held only at the fag end of proceedings.


Not adjudicating upon and communicating decisions on applications made during adjudication proceedings including.


Application by Lalit Modi seeking cross-examinations of Mr. Peter Griffiths,  Mr. Ajay Kumar; of RBI who advised ED that the concerned account was a capital account.


Not summoning the witnesses who were relevant and whose statements were relied upon in the complaint despite there being a specific provision in the FEMA adjudication rules in this regard.


Not taking on record evidence filed as defense evidence and not granting an opportunity to lead defense evidence by Lalit Modi despite the request being made in this regard and not granting an opportunity to conclude the oral arguments.


Mehmood Abdi


General Counsel of Lalit Kumar Modi

N Srinivasan Cross Examination
N Srinivasan believes everyone else was responsible for the FEMA violations except him. Former BCCI secretary Mr. N Srinivasan appeared today before the Special Director, Enforcement Directorate, Mumbai, for cross examination by Lalit Modi’s lawyers on his statement to ED in respect of alleged FEMA violations i.e. transfer of huge funds from India by BCCI to Cricket South Africa for hosting IPL season 2 (2009).
Naseer Khan Cross Examination
Mr. A.K. Naseer Khan, Chief Manager, State Bank of Travancore, now State Bank of India was put to cross examination by Lalit Modi Lawyers namely Swadeep Singh Hora and Abhishek Singh before the Special Director of Enforcement Directorate, Mumbai. Naseer Khan as manager of the then State Bank of Tavencore was instrumental in transfer of funds to Cricket South Africa (CSA) for hosting IPL season 2 in South Africa. Transfer of funds to foreign entity without approval of RBI is the bsis of alleged FEMA violation.
Prasanna Kannan misleading ED to protect boss Srinivasan
Prasanna Kannan misleading ED to protect boss Srinivasan Prasanna Kannan, the Chief Financial Officer of BCCI-IPL was cross-examined by Lalit Modi's lawyers Swadeep Singh Hora and Abhishek Singh. Kannan is a India Cement employee who according to his own admission was seconded by India Cement to BCCI when Srinivasan was office bearer in BCCI. When Srinivasan was Secretary of BCCI, Kannan was posted in the Secretariat. When Srinivasan was Treasurer, Kannan was in the treasury. Ultimately, he was assisting Srinivasan in the BCCI.
Update of Cross Examination
As the cross examination of top bcci officials by Lalit Modi Lawyers is underway, truth about the onus of alleged FEMA violations by office bearers of BCCI is revealing like onion rings. Shashank Manohar and Prof. Shetty have already been cross examined by Lalit Modi's counsels Swadeep Hora and Abhishek Singh.
N Srinivasan seeks an adjournment to a future date
The cross examination of BCCI officials is underway before the the special director of enforcement directorate at Mumbai. Mr. N Srinivasan and Prasanna Kannan were summoned to appear before the adjudicating authority on Wednesday 7 March 2018. However N Srinivasan has sought an adjournment to a future date.
Shashank Manohar and Prof. Ratnakar Shetty Cross Examination
Under the Honourable Bombay High Court Order dated 30 January 2018 where by the Special Director of the Enforcement Directorate was directed to summon all those co- noticees and others whose statements have been relied by ED for framing the showcause notice in which Lalit Modi is also a noticee.
Access to the replies filed by the co-noticees
Pursuant to Order date 30th January 2018 in Writ Petition No. 2803 of 2015 filed in Bombay High Court Special Director of the Enforcement Directorate, Mumbai issued summons the co-noticees for their cross examination by Lalit Modi lawyers in respect of the show cause notice dated 25th November 2011 wherein the allegations about alleged FEMA violation are being investigated against Lalit Modi and then BCCI high officials namely Shri. Sundar Raman, Shri. Chirayu Amin, Shri. Ratnakar Shetty, Shri. Shashank Manohar, Shri. N.Srinivasan, Shri. Prasanna Kannan, Shri. M.P. Pandove amongst others
BCCI members cross examination before Special Director, ED
Press Release
In pursuance of directions issued by the Bombay High Court in respect of allegations regarding FEMA violations in the conduct of the Indian Premier League (IPL) in South Africa in the year 2009, the erstwhile BCCI top brass Mr. N. Srinivasan, Mr. Chirayu Amin, Mr. Shashank Manohar, Mr. Sundar Raman, Mr. M.P. Pandove etc. were to be cross-examined by Mr Lalit Modi’s counsels Mr Swadeep Hora and Mr Abhishek Singh. The cross examination was to take place before Special Director, Enforcement Directorate, who is the Adjudicating Authority under directions of the Bombay High Court. However, the erstwhile BCCI top officials appear to have developed cold feet at the prospect of being cross-examined by Mr Modi’s legal team.
High Court relief for RCA office-bearers
The Honourable Rajasthan High Court held that the no-confidence motion brought out by Amin Pathan was wholly illegal and arbitrary, as the meeting was held without giving notice and without the requisite notice period of 21 days.
Modi inducted into the Advisory Board of Amanresorts
The President and Managing Director of Modi Enterprises and Architect & Founder of IPL has been inducted into the Advisory Board of the prestigious luxury hospitality chain Amanresorts, which is a playground of the rich and famous worldwide.
Dark Days ahead for world cricket
It is truly a sad day in world cricket as N Srinivasan takes over as the Chairman of the ICC today.
Statement attributable to Mr. Mehmood Abdi – Deputy President RCA
The action of the BCCI speaks volumes about its sheer arrogance and utter disregard for the law of the land and public sentiment, as it has demonstrated with the ban on the RCA in a most unfair and undemocratic manner.
RCA Poll Results Declaration Deferred Again by Supreme Court until March 11th 2014
Covert Surveillance operation in London on retired Justice Mudgal & Lalit Modi
24x7 surveillance using 6 teams in 3 Audi cars and bikes were involved in the operation.
Giles Clarke
“In May 2010 Giles Clarke CBE, Chairman of the England and Wales Cricket Board, sent an email to the President of the Board of Control for Cricket In India, the contents of which were subsequently widely reported in the British and international media which resulted in libel proceedings being issued by Lalit Modi. This statement confirms that the parties have agreed to settle the litigation on confidential terms.”
London High Court annuls bankruptcy order
Press release
Lalit Modi's position on a bankruptcy order he maintained "should never have been made" has been vindicated after it was annulled in the High Court in London.
ICC lacks strong leadership in current times: ex-CEO Lorgat
The former ICC boss said barring Khawaja's peace slogans on shoes showed ICC lacked consistency in applying its rules
Waugh warns cricket boards for ignoring Test cricket
Australia Great Warns ICC, BCCI Over 'Irrelevant Legacy'